Hi Tbone17,
thanks for your feedback, we appreciate it! :)
Your log file doesn't show any warning whatsoever, so we'll have to dig a bit deeper here.
First of all, I'd ask you to double-check if all files and folders included in the backup job are readable for BackWPup. Permissions of 0755 for folders and 0644 for files would be sufficient. BackWPup usually warns in the log file when it cannot read fiels or folders, but just in case let's make sure permissions are set correctly.
Once you verified permissions, please re-configure your backup job and set Archive Format to Tar GZip just for the sake of testing. Does that produce the same result?